Table of Contents
Below is a second article by Dr. David Fawley on how Vedanta and Yoga are actually in many ways one and the same, his first article on the subject is (here). I've been speaking to many Hindus who want to keep the two traditions apart because Yoga talks about gaining Siddhi (magic) powers and Hindus don't want Vedanta by extension to look foolish. As I already pondered (here) we must understand how both Eddy's Christian Science and Vedantic thinking lead to these conclusions, it must be some inherent function of the philosophy. Vedanta is much more difficult to understand than Christian Science, but if you start out thinking about Christian Science and understand how it leads to magical thinking, you might be able to pick up on the same mechanism inherent in Vedanta-Yoga and Hinduism.
https://www.vedanet.com/yoga-vedanta-the-highest-teaching-of-yoga/
YOGA-VEDANTA: THE HIGHEST TEACHING OF YOGA
Dr David Frawley
November 5, 2020
Yoga is defined as the unity of the individual Self or reincarnating consciousness, Jivatman, with the universal or transcendent Self, Paramatman. The nature of this unity is best explained in Vedantic texts like Upanishads, Bhagavad Gita and Mahabharata, as well as in later Vedanta Shastras.
To truly understand Yoga and what it means by unity with the higher Self one should study Vedanta.
Yoga-Vedanta Comes to the West
Yoga first came to the western world in the context of Yoga-Vedanta through the teachings of Swami Vivekananda, the great disciple of Paramahansa Ramakrishna, who visited the West at the turn of the twentieth century. Swami Rama Tirtha, who followed shortly after Vivekananda, emphasized Vedanta. Paramahansa Yoganananda, who settled in the United States in 1920, also gave importance to Vedanta in his teachings.
Swami Sivananda of Rishikesh, whose many disciples taught Yoga globally, emphasized Yoga-Vedanta, as did Swami Rama of the Himalayan Institute. Maharishi Mahesh Yogi highlighted Veda and Vedanta in his TM or Transcendental Meditation movement. Bhagavan Ramana Maharshi’s teachings set forth a direct path of Advaita Vedanta as part of Jnana Yoga, the Yoga of knowledge. Sri Aurobindo brought out his Integral Yoga based on Vedantic philosophy from his perspective.
Srila Prabhupada of ISKCON and Krishna Consciousness taught Bhakti Vedanta, a devotional approach to Vedanta. Krishnamacharya, guru of BKS Iyengar and Pattabhi Jois, was a teacher in the tradition in the Visishtadvaita tradition of Sri Ramanuja or qualified non-dualistic Vedanta.
Yet few disciples of these Yoga-Vedanta gurus, particularly those who emphasize Yoga as asana, note the Vedantic connections to their lineages. They rarely make Vedanta an essential component of their approach to Yoga, if they study it at all. Because of this neglect that has increased over time, deeper Vedantic approaches to Yoga, particularly through Self-inquiry, meditation and Samadhi are seldom understood or taught in the West, and the term Yoga-Vedanta has fallen into the background.
Vedic Basis of Yoga
The term Yoga arises from the Vedas, occurring first in the Rigveda and becoming common in later Vedic texts like the Upanishads. The Bhagavad Gita is the key yogic teaching of Sri Krishna, who is Yogeshvara and Yogavatara, the authority on Yoga and avatar of Yoga, who taught the original Yoga to Vivasvan and Manu himself, the founder of the Vedic line of teachings in this yuga or world-age.
Yoga is rooted in the Vedas and Vedic philosophy. The Yoga Sutras are a Vedic Darshana or philosophy and follow the authority of the Vedas, Upanishads and Bhagavad Gita. Traditional commentators on the Yoga Sutras refer to Vedic texts to explain the Sutras. Yoga, as noted in the Yoga Sutras, aims at the realization of the Purusha or Atman, the inner Self, Seer and Pure Consciousness beyond body and mind, time, space and Prakriti. This is Yoga as a Path of Self-Realization, a term commonly used today. While Vedic philosophies explain the nature of the Purusha/Atman in different ways, the core approach remains the same.
Yoga-Vedanta
The subject of Yoga is dealt with extensively in Vedantic texts. The numerous teachings of Adi Shankara on Advaita Vedanta address the eight limbs of Yoga, starting with carefully examining the Yamas and Niyamas for purifying the mind . He explains in depth the different types of Samadhi mentioned in the Yoga Sutras, including the highest state of yogic meditation of Nirvikalpa Samadhi in more detail perhaps than any other teacher. He delineates the Yoga practices of Jnana, Bhakti, Karma, Hatha and Raja Yoga. The famous text Yoga Vasishta similarly teaches Yoga and Vedanta together as a unitary teaching. Such explanations are not merely theoretical but deeply experiential.
Not all Vedantic teachers may embrace every aspect of Yoga Sutra or Samkhya philosophy, or afford the different practices of Yoga the same importance. Adi Shankara criticizes some concepts of Samkhya-Yoga, for example their view that Purushas are many, though he accepts most of the system. Yet Shankara never criticizes Yoga in the context of Sri Krishna and the Bhagavad Gita, or Upanishadic references.
To truly understand Yoga at a deep level, one must study and understand Vedanta, not just as an abstract philosophy but as a practical way of Self-realization. Just as there are several different approaches to Yoga, so too there are different approaches to Vedanta.
Our teachings emphasize the Yoga-Vedanta connection in our articles, books and courses going back nearly fifty years. We delineate a Vedantic connection with Ayurveda, Jyotish, and all Vedic knowledge systems. We teach Vedantic Ayurveda and Vedantic Jyotish, applying these systems as a way of Self-knowledge and Self-realization according to Vedanta. To understand anything yogic or Vedic you should learn Vedanta – and practice it in your daily meditation and ongoing awareness.
You are the Self of all beings, the Supreme Atman, as Vedanta teaches!
Vamadeva Shastri (David Frawley)
